Menu guide
Bahama Breeze Desserts Menu & Prices
The Bahama Breeze desserts menu leans hard into tropical flavors — coconut, pineapple, key lime and dulce de leche all make an appearance — and it's priced simply, with everything falling between $5.79 and $6.79. After a plate of jerk chicken or wood-grilled shrimp, this is where the island theme gets its sweet finish, and the portions are generous enough that one dessert can easily be shared between two people.
The lineup is a nice balance of citrusy-bright and rich-and-chocolatey. On the lighter side, Rebecca's Key Lime Pie and the Coconut Pineapple Cake capture that classic Caribbean sweetness; on the indulgent end, the Chocolate Island and Dulce de Leche Cheesecake are the ones to order when you want something decadent. The Warm Chocolate Pineapple Upside Down Cake splits the difference, pairing warm cake with tropical fruit. Because prices are so close together, you can pick purely by craving rather than budget.
Bahama Breeze desserts price list
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Rebecca's Key Lime Pie | $5.79 | 1050 |
| Coconut Pineapple Cake | $6.29 | — |
| Banana Nut Bread Supreme | $6.49 | — |
| Dulce de Leche Cheesecake | $6.49 | — |
| Warm Chocolate Pineapple Upside Down Cake | $6.49 | — |
| Chocolate Island | $6.79 | 1040 |
Prices vary by location. Calories are from Bahama Breeze's published nutrition guide (effective May 2026); items the guide doesn't individually list are marked "—" (recipes and menu items change over time). Confirm at bahamabreeze.com.
What to order
If it's your first time, Rebecca's Key Lime Pie is the signature, most-recommended dessert and also the cheapest at $5.79. Chocolate lovers should go straight for the Chocolate Island, the richest option on the list. For something warm, the Warm Chocolate Pineapple Upside Down Cake is a comforting, tropical-tinged choice. Any of these pairs well with a coffee or one of the after-dinner specialty drinks — and since desserts are shareable, ordering one for the table is an easy way to end a meal without overdoing it.
Planning the whole visit? Work back from here through the chicken entrées or seafood entrées, or start the evening with half-price starters at happy hour.
FAQ
How much are desserts at Bahama Breeze? They're all between $5.79 and $6.79, with Rebecca's Key Lime Pie the cheapest and the Chocolate Island the priciest.
What is the most popular dessert at Bahama Breeze? Rebecca's Key Lime Pie is the signature, most-recommended dessert.
Are Bahama Breeze desserts big enough to share? Generally yes — portions are generous and most are easy to split between two.
Does Bahama Breeze have chocolate dessert? Yes — the Chocolate Island and the Warm Chocolate Pineapple Upside Down Cake are the chocolate-forward choices.
About the author — Emman runs the menu guides at FindMenuPrices, an independent site tracking casual-dining and fast-food prices. We keep item names exactly as written and flag averages rather than guaranteed local prices. Corrections welcome via the contact page.
FindMenuPrices is independent and not affiliated with Bahama Breeze or Darden. Prices are representative U.S. averages and vary by location.